When you stay at Sand Cay Beach Resort on Longboat Key, you’re not just signing up for sugar-white sands and dreamy Gulf sunsets—you’re stepping into one of Florida’s most flavorful seafood hubs. Thanks to its proximity to Sarasota Bay and the Gulf of Mexico, Longboat Key and the surrounding area are brimming with world-class seafood restaurants. Best part? Many of the best ones are within a 10-minute drive from your condo.
So if your idea of paradise includes shrimp cocktail and ocean breezes, this curated list of must-try seafood spots near Sand Cay will help you plan your next indulgent meal. Bon appétit!
1. Dry Dock Waterfront Grill
Arguably the most iconic seafood stop on the island, Dry Dock offers panoramic views and a menu that’s heavy on the Gulf’s greatest hits. Their grouper sandwich is legendary, and the lobster bisque has local fans lining up for lunch. Snag a seat on the deck during sunset and prepare for food and photo nirvana.
Distance from Sand Cay: 4 minutes
2. Shore Longboat Key
Polished yet laid-back, Shore is a beachfront restaurant with a modern coastal vibe and equally elevated cuisine. Their scallop risotto and grilled octopus are showstoppers. Perfect for date nights or a refined group dinner.
Distance: 5 minutes
3. Mar Vista Dockside Restaurant and Pub
Old Florida ambiance? Check. Fresh-off-the-boat seafood? Double check. Located in a 1912 historic beach cottage under a canopy of buttonwood trees, Mar Vista is best known for its stone crab claws and island shrimp. Enjoy barefoot dining right on the beach.
Distance: 9 minutes
4. Lazy Lobster of Longboat Key
The Lazy Lobster delivers upscale fare in a casual setting, which makes it ideal for families and couples alike. Try the lobster escargot (seriously!) or coconut-encrusted snapper. Bonus: there’s a full kids’ menu.
Distance: 3 minutes
5. Whitney’s LBK
This former gas station turned seafood gem is full of character—and fresh local flavor. Their blackened mahi tacos and ceviche are cult favorites, and the funky coastal décor makes it perfect for Instagram-worthy bites.
Distance: 7 minutes
6. Euphemia Haye Restaurant & Haye Loft
A two-in-one dining experience, Euphemia Haye downstairs offers romantic fine dining, while the Haye Loft upstairs is all about live jazz and a killer dessert room. The pecan-crusted grouper? Worth every penny.
Distance: 6 minutes
7. Chart House
Just over the bridge in Sarasota, this national name still manages to feel local thanks to fresh-catch specials and gorgeous marina views. Try the macadamia-crusted mahi or the ahi tuna poke bowl.
Distance: 10 minutes
8. Viento Kitchen + Bar
Located inside Zota Beach Resort, Viento serves up a high-end experience without the high-stress fuss. Their sea bass in miso glaze is unforgettable, and the beachside fire pits make it a great evening hangout.
Distance: 2 minutes
9. Blue Dolphin Café
Perfect for seafood lovers who like their catch with a side of pancakes. Blue Dolphin is a charming breakfast and lunch spot with hearty seafood omelets, shrimp BLTs, and unbeatable morning vibes.
Distance: 3 minutes
10. Lo’Key Tiki Bar & Grill
Just across the bay in Cortez, Lo’Key is quirky, fun, and loaded with local color. Their crab cakes, fish tacos, and frozen cocktails are perfect for a laid-back afternoon after a morning at the beach.
Distance: 10 minutes
Tips for a Seamless Seafood Adventure:
- Reservations: During peak season (December–April), most restaurants book out a few days in advance—especially those on the water.
- Dress Code: Most places listed here are resort casual, though a few (like Euphemia Haye) are more upscale.
- Transportation: Don’t want to drive? Consider using the Longboat Key trolley or a local rideshare for a stress-free evening.
Final Thoughts
There’s no shortage of delicious seafood just minutes from Sand Cay Beach Resort. Whether you want fine dining or fish tacos with your feet in the sand, this area has something to satisfy every kind of seafood lover. Use this list to plan your culinary adventures—and don’t forget to leave room for Key lime pie.
